Best Overall Rock Album
First off, I am not the biggest Fleetwood Mac fan. I do love their music, though. I have to say that "Rumours" is, to me, the best "overall" rock album. But why? you might ask. Is it the music? Is it the lyrics? Is it the sound engineer? No, not exactly. It's all of that and more.
It's the commitment of all the members of Fleetwood Mac to honor the music above their own feelings. The artistic and creative release of each artist's mangled emotions amidst their incredible vulnerabilities with each other during the recording of "Rumours." Save Mick Fleetwood, who was facing divorce with his wife Jenny Boyd, sister to the famous Patti Boyd, who was married to George Harrison and Eric Clapton and was the muse for many a tune such as "Layla," "Wonderful Tonight" by Clapton and "Something" by Harrison. At least Mick Fleetwood didn't have to be in the same room with Jenny while that was happening. I can't say the same for the other 4 songwriting members.
It's a famous story, and probably everyone knows it, but you had Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks on the outs during recording, as well as Christine McVie and John McVie. "Go Your Own Way," written by Buckingham and directed at Nicks, is one example. Then you have "You Make Loving Fun," which Christine McVie wrote about the lighting director for the band that she was dating while still married to John. Then there is Buckingham's "Never Going Back Again," which he wrote while starting to date someone new. He didn't want to repeat the mistake of his previous relationship mistakes and had no plans to go back to Nicks. I didn't forget Stevie Nicks's contribution of "Dreams" about Lindsey.
"Rumours" was born of deep pain, confusion, and vulnerability. All four songwriters channeled their emotions brilliantly, and I can't say that about any other album in rock history. I'm not talking about a band member who had to be fired because they weren't pulling their weight, like Brian Jones of the Stones. I am talking about writing songs about the people still in your life—right there to listen and respond to songs about themselves and sticking it out anyway.
Oh ya, and the music and lyrics were magic, to boot! Brilliant. Revisit "Rumours" on Spotify.